June Yu BooksJune Yu BooksJune Yu BooksJune Yu Books
  • Home
  • About
  • Writing
  • Speaking
  • Blog & Resources
    • Blog
    • Writers
    • Teachers & Youth Leaders
    • Media
  • Contact
  • BUY

What if you lived in a digital dictatorship… or do we already?

    Home Privacy What if you lived in a digital dictatorship… or do we already?
    NextPrevious

    What if you lived in a digital dictatorship… or do we already?

    By June Yu | Privacy, Technology | 0 comment | 3 April, 2019 | 0

    A society where individuals are under round-the-clock surveillance. You gain or lose “social credit” according to your behaviour, actions and even thoughts.

    It sounds like an episode of Black Mirror or the 21st Century version of Orwell’s 1984 but it’s real. It’s a mandatory ranking system of citizens in China, due to be completed by 2020. If you have a bad social credit score, you’ll lose privileges. For example, you may not be able to book a flight or train ticket. You’ll have trouble getting your children into the best schools. The most lucrative jobs will be closed to you. Banks won’t want to lend you money. Even your love life may slide if your low score shows up on a dating website.

    You can read about China’s social credit system here and here and here.

    Some Chinese people like the social credit system, saying it makes them better citizens. Others, especially those who express opposing views to the government, end up blacklisted. Just ask Liu Hu, a journalist in China, who writes about censorship and government corruption.

    We like to shudder and point the finger at China over dictator-like control. But really, are Western societies so different? In many cases, we’re only a step or two away from the kind of surveillance China is now implementing. It appears their social credit system depends on being linked up to databases that reveal citizen behaviour – what they purchase, their traffic violations, failure to pay taxes or loans and so on. Some of this data is kept in private enterprise systems and others in government records. As this Wired article says, “What’s troubling is when those private systems link up to the government rankings.”

    However, this is not so different to the idea of a national identity card, which has never got up and running in countries including the US and Australia, due to privacy and civil liberties concerns. But such a card or system is very possible. I once worked with a database expert who said to me, “I don’t understand why people object to a national identity card. All the information already exists in different databases. A national card would just pull it all together under one system.” But citizens of Western countries dislike any systems that suggest government or business could be keeping closer watch on our behaviour. We value our freedom.

    Or is it that we want the freedom to choose whether we give faceless entities personal information? We don’t want governments to be watching us… yet so many of us voluntarily hand over slabs of data through our shopping habits on eBay, our credit cards, and even what we post on social media. If we get a parking or speeding fine, a good number of us will get onto Facebook and rant about the unfairness of the traffic infringement. How does that make sense? We wouldn’t want such an infringement to be used against us in an official social credit system… yet we publicly tell the world we got one and slam the system that gave it to us! Freedom of speech allows citizens in Western countries to do that without fear of reprisal.

    What if question… would you a social credit system similar to China’s in your country? What would be the advantages and disadvantages?

    Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

    data, government, surveillance, technology

    June Yu

    More posts by June Yu

    Related Post

    • Sharing food

      What if you shared everything from transport to food? Bring it on or back off?

      By June Yu | 0 comment

      It’s eerily quiet on the roads right now because of these dastardly lockdowns. That means thousands of cars are sitting in garages, unused. Many of us have had less need for a car as we’reRead more

    • Space vs Spirituality

      What if Richard Branson collaborated with Buddhists?

      By June Yu | 0 comment

      I had a weird moment last month. In between lockdowns, my family visited the Great Stupa in Bendigo. Here I was struck by the scale of the vision for their sacred building. Their plan isRead more

    • What if you went shopping

      What if you went shopping… and you were entirely served by bots?

      By June Yu | 0 comment

        No humans allowed! Ridiculous? Well, it’s exactly what is happening, right now, in the heart of Singapore’s Central Business District. Singtel’s latest innovation – Unboxed  – is Singapore’s first unmanned 24-hour phone sales store.Read more

    • Jamila's Armour

      SHORT STORY: Jamila’s Armour

      By June Yu | 2 comments

      This short story is intended to highlight various double standards, contradictions and ironies related to cosmetics and the role of women. Read the story below or skip straight to More on why I wrote thisRead more

    • What if… your clothing told you how to exercise correctly?

      By June Yu | 0 comment

      If you’re into yoga, you’ve had the experience of contorting yourself into position to streee-tch those tight and achy muscles. But have you ever wondered whether you’re doing that yoga stretch properly? Enter the smartRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    You’re invited to join the What If conversation

    Don’t miss a blog! Sign up to the What If Report. It will travel the ether to your inbox every three weeks with the latest blog posts related to science, genetics, ethical dilemmas and other bits and pieces.

    Recent Posts

    • Miscreation? Book Launch
    • What if… working from home was an amazing immersive experience?
    • October book reads for you
    • September book reads for you
    • What if you shared everything from transport to food? Bring it on or back off?

    Recent Comments

    • June Yu on SHORT STORY: Jamila’s Armour
    • Chris on SHORT STORY: Jamila’s Armour

    Categories

    • Animals
    • Books
    • Clothing
    • Environment
    • Fashion
    • Fiction
    • Flash Fiction
    • Genetics
    • Humanity
    • Miscreation
    • Privacy
    • Science
    • Space
    • Spirituality
    • Sustainable
    • Technology
    • Writing
    • Home
    • About
    • Writing
    • Speaking
    • Blog & Resources
      • Blog
      • Writers
      • Teachers & Youth Leaders
      • Media
    • Contact
    • BUY
    Copyright © 2018 June Yu. All Rights Reserved.
    • Home
    • About
    • Writing
    • Speaking
    • Blog & Resources
      • Blog
      • Writers
      • Teachers & Youth Leaders
      • Media
    • Contact
    • BUY
    June Yu Books